Last Thursday, 5 November, was Bonfire Night in the UK!
Every year, people across the country celebrate with bonfires, fireworks and gatherings with family and friends. But have you ever wondered why this tradition exists? And what’s the economics behind it?
The story takes us all the way back to 1605, when a group of people attempted to blow up the Houses of Parliament and assassinate King James I.
Of course, we could dig a little deeper into the history and explain that the group consisted of Catholics plotting to kill a Protestant king. But that would take us into a much longer story involving religious conflict between Catholics and Protestants in England, including the establishment of the Church of England.
So, to keep things simple, the plan, known as the Gunpowder Plot, was discovered before it could be carried out, and one of those involved, Guy Fawkes, was arrested while guarding barrels of gunpowder beneath Parliament.
Following the failed plot, people lit bonfires to celebrate the King’s survival. Over time, this became an annual tradition, with bonfires, fireworks and, historically, effigies of Guy Fawkes placed on the flames (something you are much less likely to see nowadays!).
More than 400 years later, Bonfire Night remains part of British culture. But what does any of this have to do with economics?
Let’s change scenarios and travel from the 17th century to the 21st. Imagine a typical Bonfire Night.
You are at home, sitting comfortably on your sofa, enjoying a good book and a nice drink. You have been looking forward to a peaceful evening.
Meanwhile, your neighbour has decided to celebrate Bonfire Night by lighting a bonfire and setting off fireworks in their garden. For those reading from outside the UK, you might be surprised to learn that it is legal here to set off fireworks in your own garden, subject to certain restrictions!
For your neighbour, the evening is fantastic! They enjoy the warmth of the fire, the atmosphere and the opportunity to celebrate a long-standing tradition.
But for you? Not quite so fantastic.
Smoke from the bonfire drifts towards your house. You can smell it through the windows, and the noise from the fireworks makes it difficult to concentrate on your book. Your peaceful evening has suddenly become considerably less enjoyable.
And here is where economics comes in!
When someone else’s enjoyment comes at your expense, in economics, we call this a negative externality.
A negative externality occurs when an activity imposes a cost on a third party who is not directly involved in that activity, and that cost is not fully taken into account by those undertaking it.
Your neighbour considers the benefits of having a bonfire, such as enjoyment, warmth and entertainment, alongside the private costs, such as purchasing wood, fireworks and preparing the garden.
However, they may not consider the costs imposed on you, which in this case include smoke, noise and air pollution. Economists refer to these as external costs.
As economists, we need to consider the total cost to society of an activity, which includes both private and external costs. When people make decisions without taking these external costs into account, the result can be what economists call market failure.
In this case, your neighbour may decide whether to have a bonfire based on their own private costs and benefits, without fully accounting for the inconvenience experienced by those living nearby. This creates a divergence between private and social costs and can lead to more bonfire activity than would be socially optimal.
Now, think about this on a much larger scale.
Imagine a proposal to build an airport near a residential neighbourhood. The airport operator considers the costs of construction, staff and operations, alongside the expected benefits and revenues. But what about the people living nearby who will experience aircraft noise and air pollution?
If these external costs are not fully taken into account, the airport could generate more flights than would be socially optimal. The same economic principle applies, whether we are talking about a bonfire in someone’s garden or an airport serving millions of passengers!
But wait… does this mean we should stop celebrating Bonfire Night?
Not necessarily!
Bonfire Night also generates benefits. People enjoy celebrating together, communities come together, and traditions are passed from one generation to another.
The economic question is not simply whether bonfires are good or bad, but whether the benefits of the activity outweigh all the costs, including those experienced by other people.
This is why as economists we think of ways to internalise externalities: encouraging individuals and businesses to take into account the costs their decisions impose on others.
For example, choosing organised community displays instead of numerous individual garden bonfires, using less-polluting alternatives, or being considerate about when and where bonfires take place could help reduce some of these external costs.
And if you allow me to briefly return to our airport example, similar principles apply. Governments might introduce restrictions on night flights, impose noise-related charges on airlines, or require airports to invest in noise reduction measures. These policies aim to reduce external costs or encourage those generating them to take them into account when making decisions.
Of course, none of these solutions necessarily eliminates the externality entirely. The objective is to achieve a better balance between the benefits of an activity and the costs it imposes on society.
So, next Bonfire Night, whether you are lighting a bonfire or trying to enjoy a quiet evening with a book, remember that even a 400-year-old tradition can provide a perfect example of economics in everyday life!

Leave a Reply